Backyard Wrestling 2: There Goes the Neighborhood (2004) followed up the cult hit with even more chaotic environments and brutal weapon-based combat. Released on PS2 and Xbox, it featured indie wrestlers, Insane Clown Posse members, and outlandish stages like junkyards and strip clubs. The game leaned heavily into shock value and hardcore culture.

Gameplay emphasized interactive arenas where players could use almost anything as a weapon. The roster was expanded, and customization options allowed players to create over-the-top brawlers. While critics panned it for clunky controls and repetitive mechanics, fans of the subculture appreciated its unapologetic commitment to hardcore mayhem. It stands as a time capsule of early-2000s edgy gaming.