Fire Pro Wrestling (2012) for Xbox Live Arcade was a controversial departure from the series’ traditional formula. Instead of the classic 2D grappling system, it used Xbox avatars as wrestlers in a simplified arcade-style game. Players could customize their avatars with moves and gear, then compete in fast-paced matches.

While lighthearted and accessible, longtime fans criticized it for straying too far from Fire Pro’s simulation roots. It offered fun multiplayer and creative freedom but lacked the depth that defined the franchise. Today, it is remembered more as an oddity than a true Fire Pro entry.